Why Do People Return to Abusive Relationships? The Cycle of Abuse, Trauma Bonding and the Hope That Things Will Be Different

You remember the moment you decided it was over.
The final conversation. The words that hurt. The night you realised you couldn't keep living like this.
Maybe you had even left.
You told a friend. You started feeling a little freer. You promised yourself that this time, you wouldn't go back.
Then a message arrives.
"I miss you."
"I understand what I did."
"I promise things will be different this time."
And suddenly, something inside you begins to waver.
You remember the good times. The closeness. The person you fell in love with. The future you imagined together.
And perhaps you find yourself asking:
If I know this relationship hurt me, why does part of me still want to go back?
It is one of the most complicated questions when we talk about abusive relationships and domestic abuse.
Because from the outside, the decision may seem simple.
But on the inside, there are emotions, fears, hope, dependence, memories and sometimes very real danger.
To understand why people stay in abusive relationships or return after leaving, we need to explore several dynamics: the cycle of abuse, trauma bonding, coercive control and the difficulty of letting go not only of a person, but also of the hope that the relationship could have been different.
Why Do People Return to Abusive Relationships Even When They Know They Are Being Hurt?
People may return to an abusive relationship for a combination of emotional and practical reasons.
Sometimes, it is love and longing. Sometimes, it is the hope that their partner will change. In other situations, there may be fear, threats, financial dependence, shared children, social isolation or difficulty building an independent life.
Sometimes, the relationship includes periods of harm alongside moments of warmth, reconciliation and closeness. These shifts can make it harder to walk away and strengthen the hope that things really will be different this time.
Returning to an abusive relationship does not mean the abuse wasn't serious. Nor does it mean the person experiencing it wanted the abuse or is responsible for it.
To understand this complexity, it helps to begin with what is known as the cycle of abuse.
What Is the Cycle of Abuse in a Relationship?
The cycle of abuse is a model that describes a pattern found in some abusive relationships: rising tension, an abusive incident, attempts at reconciliation and a period of relative calm.
The model can help explain why it may be difficult to see the full picture when a relationship also includes good moments.
Stage 1: Tension Begins to Build
Something in the atmosphere changes.
One partner becomes increasingly critical.
The other reacts angrily to small things.
There is a sense that you need to be careful with your words, reactions and decisions.
You may begin asking yourself:
What did I do wrong?
How can I prevent the next argument?
At this stage, someone may begin adjusting their behaviour to keep the peace.
Stage 2: Abuse Occurs
The tension turns into abusive behaviour.
This may involve humiliation, shouting, threats, intimidation, monitoring, financial control, or physical or sexual abuse.
Sometimes, the abusive partner blames the person they have harmed:
"Look what you made me do."
"If you hadn't behaved like that, this wouldn't have happened."
But responsibility for the abuse lies with the person who chooses to behave abusively.
Stage 3: Reconciliation and Promises Follow
After the abuse, there may be a sudden change.
An apology.
Flowers.
An emotional conversation.
A promise to start therapy.
Or words such as:
"I don't know what came over me. You know I love you."
This can be an incredibly confusing moment.
Because the person who caused the harm is now also the person offering comfort,
closeness and hope.
Stage 4: A Period of Calm
For a while, things seem different.
There are fewer arguments.
More attention.
Perhaps even a feeling that the relationship has returned to how it was in the beginning.
Then, if the abusive behaviour has not changed, the pattern may repeat.
Does Every Abusive Relationship Follow This Cycle?
No.
It is important to understand that the cycle of abuse is one possible model, not a description of every abusive relationship.
Some relationships involve no apologies or periods of reconciliation. In others, the abuse is unpredictable, while some involve ongoing control without dramatic incidents.
You do not need to recognise every stage of the cycle to take abusive behaviour seriously.
Even if there are no flowers after the abuse, and even if there is no obvious moment when everything explodes, abuse may still be present.
What Is Trauma Bonding?
Trauma bonding is a term used to describe a strong emotional attachment that may develop within a relationship involving abuse, an imbalance of power and sometimes periods of closeness, relief or reconciliation.
The term does not refer to two people who have simply been through a difficult experience together.
It describes a dynamic in which attachment to the person causing harm may become stronger within an environment of fear, uncertainty and dependence.
For example:
A woman experiences days of criticism, accusations and emotional distance.
Then her partner hugs her, apologises and tells her she is the most important person in his life.
The relief she feels is enormous.
Not only because the moment feels good, but also because the tension that came before it has eased.
Over time, she may begin waiting for those moments of closeness and holding on to them as evidence that the relationship can be good.
Why Do the Good Moments Make It So Hard to Leave?
Because they do not necessarily feel false to the person experiencing them.
There may have been genuine moments of love, intimacy, support and laughter.
Those memories are real.
But they do not cancel out the abuse.
The difficulty arises when we try to decide which version of the relationship is the real one.
Is it the relationship where I feel loved?
Or the one where I am afraid to express my opinion?
Sometimes, the answer is that both experiences existed within the same relationship.
Good moments are not proof that a relationship is safe. To understand the relationship, we need to look at the overall pattern.
It is also important not to use trauma bonding as an automatic diagnosis. Not every feeling of longing, love or decision to return to someone who caused harm indicates trauma bonding.
Why Do I Miss Someone Who Hurt Me?
Sometimes, the longing itself creates confusion.
You remember how deeply you were hurt.
You know why you wanted to leave.
And yet, you miss their voice, your conversations, their embrace or the way things felt at the beginning of the relationship.
Then a thought appears:
"Maybe if I miss them this much, it means I made a mistake by leaving."
But missing someone does not necessarily mean the relationship was right for you.
You can miss someone and remember that they hurt you.
You can love someone and not feel safe around them.
You can grieve the end of a relationship, even when ending it was necessary.
Sometimes, We Also Miss the Future We Imagined
Not just the person themselves.
Perhaps you wanted to start a family.
Perhaps you built a home together.
Perhaps you imagined growing old together.
When a relationship ends, we are not always saying goodbye only to what existed.
We are also saying goodbye to what we hoped it would become.
And sometimes, that loss is one of the hardest things to let go of.
Why Is the Promise "I'll Change This Time" So Powerful?
Because it speaks directly to the part of us that still holds hope.
Perhaps you have already had countless conversations.
Perhaps your partner promised never to raise their voice again.
Perhaps they said they would stop checking your phone.
And perhaps this time, the promise sounds different:
"I'm starting therapy."
"I've realised I need help."
"I don't want to lose you."
The possibility of change can create genuine hope.
But it is important to distinguish between a promise and a change in behaviour.
How Can You Tell the Difference Between a Promise and Meaningful Change?
A promise focuses on what someone says they will do.
Meaningful change is assessed through their behaviour over time.
It may help to consider questions such as:
Do they take responsibility for the harm without blaming me?
Do they acknowledge their abusive behaviour even when I do not agree to return?
Do they respect my boundaries and decisions?
Has their behaviour changed consistently, rather than only during periods when they fear losing the relationship?
Are they seeking appropriate professional help out of personal responsibility, rather than making it conditional on my return?
Even positive answers do not guarantee that the relationship is safe or that the abuse will not happen again.
Change is not measured by the intensity of an apology, but by responsibility and behaviour over time.
And you do not have to stay in a relationship or return to it to find out whether someone else is capable of changing.
Why Is It Difficult to Leave an Abusive Relationship Even When There Is No Love?
Not everyone who stays or returns does so because they miss their partner.
Sometimes, the reasons are very practical.
Financial Dependence
Perhaps there is no independent bank account.
Perhaps a partner controls the household income.
Perhaps the person has not worked for years.
Without access to money or a safe place to live, separation can seem impossible.
Shared Children
Concerns about the impact on children, parenting-time arrangements, legal disputes or threats involving the children can make decisions extremely difficult.
Fear of a Reaction or Escalation
Sometimes, a partner threatens to harm themselves, the person experiencing abuse, the children or other loved ones.
In these situations, returning to the relationship may be an attempt to avoid danger rather than a desire to resume the relationship.
Social Isolation
When someone has gradually become distanced from friends and family, they may feel they have nobody to turn to.
Loss of Self-Confidence
Ongoing criticism and humiliation can undermine someone's confidence in their ability to manage independently.
Pressure From Others
Sometimes, people around them encourage them to keep the family together, forgive or give the relationship another chance without understanding the full situation.
All of these factors illustrate why the question "Why doesn't she just leave?" misses so much of the reality.
Sometimes, a person knows exactly what they want, but does not yet have the conditions they need to make that choice safely.
Does Returning to an Abusive Relationship Mean I've Failed?
No.
People may separate and return more than once.
Sometimes, they attempt to leave before they have enough support.
Sometimes, they hope the relationship will change.
And sometimes, they return because of fear, dependence or circumstances that are not entirely within their control.
Returning does not erase the understanding you have already gained.
Nor does it remove your need for safety and support.
Instead of asking, "How did I make the same mistake again?", you might ask:
What was particularly difficult when I was away?
What support was I missing?
What made me feel that I had no other option?
What could help me feel safer now?
These questions can open up possibilities rather than adding another layer of guilt.
How Can You Cope With the Urge to Return to an Abusive Relationship?
If you feel the urge to go back, you do not have to make a decision in that moment.
You can try to understand what lies behind that desire and what may help you navigate it safely.
1. Distinguish Between Missing Someone and Feeling Safe
You might ask yourself:
What exactly am I missing right now?
The good moments?
The closeness?
The feeling of having a family?
Or perhaps the relief I felt when the arguments ended?
Then ask yourself another question:
Alongside the things I miss, did I also feel safe, respected and free to be myself?
Both answers can exist at the same time.
2. Look at the Pattern, Not Just the Latest Message
An apology can be deeply moving.
But it does not tell the whole story of the relationship.
Try thinking about the behaviour over time.
What happened after previous promises?
What actually changed?
How did I feel most of the time within the relationship?
If it is safe to do so, you can explore these questions with someone you trust.
3. Identify What You Need Right Now
Sometimes, the urge to return is connected to loneliness.
Sometimes, to financial fears.
Sometimes, to a need for comfort or belonging.
Each of these needs may have a different possible response.
If you need emotional support, you could reach out to someone safe or a professional.
If you are experiencing financial difficulties, you can explore your rights and available assistance.
If you are afraid of being harmed, it is important to contact a professional who specialises in domestic abuse.
The goal is not to ignore the need, but to find a safer way to meet it.
4. Don't Face the Decision Alone
Sometimes, one conversation can help bring clarity.
Not so someone else can decide for you.
But so you can hear yourself, access information and explore your options.
5. Be Careful About Steps That Could Lead to Escalation
In relationships involving monitoring, threats or control, suddenly cutting off contact, blocking someone on social media, changing passwords or announcing a separation may sometimes increase the risk.
There is no single recommendation that is right for everyone.
If you are concerned about your safety, consider developing a personalised safety plan with an appropriate professional before taking significant steps.
6. Remember That You Can Ask for Help Without Making a Final Decision
You do not have to promise that you will never go back.
You do not have to know whether you want to separate.
And you do not have to prove that the situation is serious enough.
You can seek information and support even while you are still unsure.
How Can You Tell if the Relationship Is Really Changing or the Same Pattern Is Repeating?
Sometimes, after a separation or crisis, it seems as though everything has changed.
Your partner is more attentive.
They apologise.
They make promises.
Perhaps they even talk about a future together.
To understand whether meaningful change is taking place, it is important to look beyond the reconciliation period.
For example:
In a repeating pattern: An abusive incident is followed by an apology, but the threats, criticism or control eventually return.
In meaningful behavioural change: The person acknowledges the harm, takes responsibility, stops justifying their behaviour and consistently works towards change over time.
Even then, positive changes do not obligate the person who experienced abuse to resume the relationship.
The question is not only whether the other person wants to change.
It is also what is safe and right for the person who experienced the harm.
How Can You Help Someone Who Keeps Returning to an Abusive Relationship?
Sometimes, it is difficult to watch from the outside.
You see a friend who has been hurt.
She cries, tells you what happened and decides to leave.
Then she goes back.
You feel frustrated.
You may even want to say:
"But we've already talked about this. Why are you doing this to yourself?"
But those words may deepen her shame and isolation.
What Can You Do Instead?
Listen without judgement.
You might say:
"I can see how complicated this is for you. I'm here if you want to talk."
Don't demand an immediate decision.
You can help someone explore their options without making separation a condition of receiving support.
Focus on safety.
Ask:
"Do you feel safe right now?"
"Is there anything that could help you feel safer?"
Offer practical help that fits their situation.
For example, you might help them find support services, accompany them to a professional appointment if they want you to, or help them access information about their rights.
Don't contact or confront the abusive partner yourself.
Direct confrontation could put the person you are trying to help at risk.
Continue being someone they can turn to, even if they return to the relationship.
Sometimes, simply knowing that support is available can make it easier to ask for help in the future.
What About the Children When a Parent Returns to an Abusive Relationship?
When children are involved, decisions become even more complicated.
A parent may worry about disrupting the children's routines, financial consequences or threats involving their relationship with the other parent.
It is important to understand that children can be affected by domestic abuse even when they are not directly targeted.
But this is not a reason to blame the parent experiencing abuse.
Responsibility for abusive behaviour lies with the person engaging in it.
When children are involved and there are concerns about abuse, it is important to seek professional guidance that considers their safety, their needs and the relevant legal and family circumstances.
Frequently Asked Questions About Returning to Toxic Relationships and the Cycle of Abuse
Why Do I Keep Going Back to an Ex Who Hurt Me?
Returning to someone who hurt you may be connected to love, longing, hope for change, fear, financial dependence or an attachment formed within an abusive dynamic.
There is not always one reason, and returning does not mean the abuse was not real.
What Is the Difference Between Love and Trauma Bonding?
Love can exist within a relationship characterised by respect, safety and independence.
Trauma bonding describes an emotional attachment that may become stronger within a dynamic involving abuse, an imbalance of power and sometimes reconciliation and relief.
Longing alone is not enough to establish that trauma bonding is present.
Does the Cycle of Abuse Occur in Every Abusive Relationship?
No.
Some relationships follow a pattern of tension, abuse, reconciliation and calm, while in others the abuse is ongoing or unpredictable.
The absence of reconciliation does not mean abuse is absent.
Why Do I Miss Someone Who Abused Me?
You may miss the good moments, the closeness, the hope that the relationship would change or the future you imagined together.
Missing someone does not prove that the relationship was safe or that leaving was a mistake.
Can Someone Who Abuses Their Partner Change?
Change is possible, but promises and apologies are not enough to demonstrate it.
Taking responsibility, stopping abusive behaviour, seeking appropriate professional help and showing consistent change over time all matter.
Even if someone changes, you are not obliged to return to them.
How Do You Stop Going Back to a Toxic Relationship?
There is no single solution that works for everyone.
You can begin by identifying what makes it difficult to stay away, building a support network, understanding your rights and developing a safety plan suited to your circumstances.
When threats or controlling behaviour are involved, it is advisable to seek professional guidance rather than taking steps that could lead to escalation.
Does Returning to an Abusive Relationship Mean I'm Choosing Abuse?
No.
Returning may happen in circumstances involving fear, pressure, dependence, hope or other complex factors.
Responsibility for the abuse remains with the person causing harm.
How Can I Help a Friend Who Keeps Returning to an Abusive Partner?
Listen without judgement, avoid ultimatums, ask what might help them feel safer and offer information about support services.
Avoid confronting their partner and respect their decisions and pace, while taking any danger seriously.
Where Can You Get Help in Israel?
If you are experiencing emotional, physical, sexual or financial abuse, threats or controlling behaviour within a relationship, you can access information and support even if you have not yet decided whether to stay or leave.
Ministry of Welfare and Social Affairs Hotline - 118: Free information, guidance and initial assistance.
Discreet Support by Text Message - 050-2270118: An option for reaching out when it is not safe to speak.
Israel Police - 100: In situations of immediate danger.
If you are concerned that your partner monitors your phone, messages or browsing history, consider contacting support services from a safe device and seeking advice about communication methods that will not put you at risk.
On The Voice Within website, you can also find information about abusive relationships, rights, support services and ways to access help.
Maybe the Question Isn't Why You Went Back, but What You Need to Have a Choice
During Domestic Violence Awareness Month, we talk a great deal about the warning signs.
What abuse is.
How to recognise it.
And the importance of leaving an abusive relationship.
But we also need to talk about what happens after someone recognises the harm.
The longing.
The hope.
The fear.
The dependence.
The moment when they almost manage to walk away, only for something to pull them back.
Because understanding that a relationship is hurting you does not always mean you already have the emotional, financial and practical conditions needed to leave safely.
So instead of asking someone who has returned to an abusive relationship:
"Why did you go back again?"
Perhaps we should ask:
"What was difficult for you when you were away?"
"What do you need to feel safer?"
"How can I help?"
The path out is not always a straight line. And returning to a relationship does not erase your right to safety, respect and a different future.
You Don't Have to Go Through This Journey Alone
At The Voice Within, we believe that understanding is an important part of creating change.
In our app, you'll find The Voice Within Journey, articles, practical tools, a supportive community and professional content covering the recognition of abusive patterns, planning, decision-making, leaving a toxic relationship, healing and recovery.
Most areas of the app are free to access, alongside the paid Experts Space and Lectures & Workshops sections.
This article is intended for general educational purposes and does not constitute a diagnosis or replace professional advice, legal guidance or an individual risk assessment. In situations involving abuse, threats or concerns about escalation, seek appropriate professional support.
















תגובות